An academic from Princeton came across the Chapman blog and wrote the following response on their Princeton blog entitled "Academic Librarian".
Read It.
*
*
*
*
*
*
A lot of people have told me or suggested that the focus should be more on tearing down Chapman's argument than focusing on the other things. I generally agree, however I've yet to find anyone other than Chapman who will defend his argument on its merit (and he said he won't comment publicly about it anymore). This entry I believe is one of the best representations of the type of incredulity I think any educated person, or at least any academic or scholar ought to experience upon examining Chapman's argument.
As far as updates go we are now over 11 pages of signatures for the petition, and I can confirm the AP story made it to print in Indy and South Bend (and I'm pretty sure Muncie but not positive). There was no tabling/petitioning today due to my investigation of the various details regarding the University's harassment policy, a trip to Vice-Provost Taylor's office, and one on one meeting with Chapman. I have every intention to resume collecting petitions Wednesday although there is some degree of bureaucratic red tape involved in officially reserving space.
**Edit 1** For the sake of disclosure, I met with Chapman primarily because I kept being asked if I had and, while I didn't really have anything to say to him, I figured there was some benefit for both of us to put a face and person behind our words and I figured that he deserves a chance to be able to say anything he had to say to me. The meeting was civil but honest.
Monday, November 16, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I actually found this that defended him...http://phibetacons.nationalreview.com/post/?q=YmM3MzRiMDY3MmE1OThmN2JiZjFhNDQyNGIwMzY0NGQ=
ReplyDeleteoh there are plenty of defenses of him of that nature... I've yet to find someone say his argument is logical, reasonable, responsible, factually correct, valid- that's what i mean by 'merit'
ReplyDeletethe only possible exception is the guy who started the petition to have me expelled: http://townhall.com/columnists/MikeAdams/2009/11/17/the_expel_kevin_casimer_petition&Comments=true?page=1
If there is no one else who will defend him on the merits, is there any rational reason to organize a campus wide protest? If you were actually spending any time debunking his claims there would be a point, but come on. In the end you're sending the message that some speech is not acceptable and should be not just refuted, but supressed.
ReplyDeleteA Campus wide protest of opinions that are so ridiculous as to not even require refutation by the very people protesting them.... Thats not responcible or productive, just petty and childish.
If you're gonna string up a strawman, at least find one which is worth beating down.
Some speech isn't acceptable for a university professor if that title is supposed to actually mean something.
ReplyDeleteThe only thing a title, such as professor, should mean is that a person has achieved a certian level of distinction in their field.
ReplyDeleteIt should not mean that person is prohibited from expressing their mind on whatever issue they feel appropriate or that it is appropriate for them to be attacked as a person for having an opinion which is unpopular.
The appropriate responince to learning of Chapman's ludricious posting is to ignore it and move on, not publize it in order to knock down an opinion virtually no one agrees with to begin with.
it would appear that firefox's spellcheck doesn't work in these comment forums
ReplyDelete*certain
*response
*ludicrous
*publicize
歐美色情免費線上電影歐美色情寫真照歐美免費色情歐美免費色情片正妹牆免費色情短片武俠色情小說永和色情波波色情波波色情網洪爺的色情小說明星色情貼圖日本成人色情影片日本卡通免費色情片日本色情网日本色情网站日本色情dvd日本色情遊戲日本色情電影av日本色情頻道日本色情論壇日本色情貼圖日本色情免費網站日本色情卡通圖日本色情影片日本色情性愛日本色情漫畫卡通日本.色情日本免費色情網站日本卡通色情影片洪爺自拍色情貼圖區洪爺色情片免費觀賞洪爺色情網站無碼貼片亞洲色情貼圖區亞洲成人色情亞亞dvd色情網亞亞免費色情交易的色情網站溫柔的色情影片人妻色情人妻色情片
ReplyDeleteApril showers bring May flowers. .........................................
ReplyDeletevery popular to u! ........................................
ReplyDelete做愛自拍照免費線上自拍影片自拍短片國中自拍免費自拍線上免費做愛影片線上免費無碼短片線上免費貼片線上免費漫畫網線上免費影片a線上直播免費a片線上洪爺線上看無碼卡通線上看影片a線上看碼線上美女影片線上做愛小影片線上做愛遊戲線上做愛影片區線上情色看線上情色貼線上情色影片免費線上無碼免費av線上短片免費線上短片免費試看線上看情色影片網線上看情色網線上看做愛小影片免費線上看A線上看A片武俠小說 亂倫小說 嘟嘟成人哈比寬頻成人
ReplyDeletenice to know you ~........................................
ReplyDelete